Framed: The Unexpected World of Hollow Square Tangrams

A hollow square tangram uses all seven pieces from the Tangram set and arranges them into a square frame that incorporates one or more voids. These voids are either trapped entirely inside the frame or form a notch in the outer edge.

After completing my tangram trilogy I wanted a project where I could research other people’s work and bring it all together in one place, rather than trying to find my own solutions and agonise over whether I had found every shape.

One Canonical Solution Per Frame

I treat each distinct frame and void arrangement as a single entry. Many entries can have the pieces arranged internally in multiple ways. I am not documenting every variation: I provide an image of just one so that I can focus on the frame itself. This saves me (and you) from the muddy rabbit hole of minor piece permutations.

No Accidental Rectangles

Putting together a frame that looks like a square to the naked eye can easily result in a subtle rectangle if the dimensions aren’t checked with a ruler. I’m sure I’ve avoided rectangles in my catalogue. If anyone wants to take this project further, this is a trap to watch out for.

Definitions

CategoryDefinition
Group A: Indented FramesThe edge of the square is interrupted by notches, nearly always looking like the two small triangles of the Tangram set.
Group B: Hybrid FramesThe frame features both an exterior notch and an internal ‘void’.
Group C: Intact Frames (True Hollows)The frame is completely intact. The ‘voids’ are entirely internal.

To avoid introducing too much jargon, below I use the word ‘notch’ to describe any empty space in the frame, whether it touches the edge of the frame or sits completely inside it. It will all make sense when you start to look at the images.

Group A: Indented Frames

The edge of the square is interrupted by notches, nearly always looking like the two small triangles of the Tangram set.

Group A: Set 1.

The notches form a medium triangle:

Group A: Set 1

Group A: Set 2.

The notches touch vertex to vertex, inside the frame:

Group A: Set 2

Group A: Set 3.

The notches touch on the edge of the frame:

Group A: Set 3

Group A: Set 4.

The notches do not touch each other; there is reflection symmetry of the whole frame:

Group A: Set 4

Group A: Set 5.

The notches do not touch each other; there is no reflection symmetry; the notches are on different corners of the frame:

Group A: Set 5

Group A: Set 6.

The notches do not touch each other; there is no reflection symmetry; one notch is at the corner of the frame and one notch is on the edge of the frame:

Group A: Set 6

Group A: Set 7.

A strange group. The notches form quadrilaterals. Moving the purple medium triangle from its starting position (right or down) produces two more frames:

Group A: Set 7

Group B: Hybrid Frames

The frame features both an exterior notch and an internal void.

Group B: Set 1.

The notches form a parallelogram:

Group B: Set 1

Group B: Set 2.

The notches form a square:

Group B: Set 2

Group B: Set 3.

The notches touch vertex to vertex:

Group B: Set 3

Group B: Set 4.

The notches do not touch each other; the internal notch touches two edges of the frame:

Group B: Set 4

Group B: Set 5.

The notches do not touch each other; the internal notch touches one edge of the frame:

Group B: Set 5

Group B: Set 6.

The internal notch is fully inside the frame; the notches touch vertex to vertex:

Group B: Set 6

Group B: Set 7.

The internal notch is fully inside the frame; the notches do not touch each other:

Group B: Set 7

Group C: Intact Frames (True Hollows)

The frame is completely intact. The voids are entirely internal.

I’ve saved my favourite group to the end.

Group C: Set 1.

The notches form a parallelogram:

Group C: Set 1

Group C: Set 2.

The notches form a medium triangle, with one vertex touching the edge of the frame:

Group C: Set 2

Group C: Set 3.

The notches form a medium triangle, with two vertices touching the edge of the frame:

Group C: Set 4.

The notches touch vertex to vertex inside the frame; both notches touch the edge of the frame:

Group C: Set 4

Group C: Set 5.

The notches touch vertex to vertex inside the frame; one notch touches the edge of the frame; one notch is fully inside the frame:

Group C: Set 5

Group C: Set 6.

The notches do not touch each other; the notches touch opposite edges of the frame:

Group C: Set 6

Group C: Set 7.

The notches do not touch each other; one notch touches the edge of the frame; one notch is fully inside the frame:

Group C: Set 8.

A strange group, which has a lot in common with Group A: Set 7. The notches form quadrilaterals. Moving the purple medium triangle from its starting position (up or left) produces two more frames:

Group C: Set 8

Total

Group A = 27 frames

Group B = 37 frames

Group C = 15 frames

This gives a total of 79 frames. I had no idea there would be this many before I started. If you know of any frames I have missed, contact me and I will include them.

Sources

I found most of the hollow squares in Elffers. But I found some that he does not include. Elffers is comprehensive: the book contains about 1,600 illustrations. But the solutions are tiny and really challenged my eyes.

Tangram: The Ancient Chinese Shapes Game by Joost Elffers (translated by R. J. Hollingdale). Penguin, 1973.

The Ancient Mystery of Tangrams: 500 Magnetic Variations on the World’s Classic Puzzles. Little, Brown and Company, 2000

I didn’t find any new hollow squares in these two books, but they are still worth owning if you want to get more into tangrams:

Tangrams by Jon Millington. Tarquin Publications, 1997

Tangrams – 330 Puzzles by Ronald C. Read. Dover Publications, 1965

Feel free to contact me if you want to make the catalogue of the hollow triangles or hollow parallelograms. I can help to get you started.

Did you enjoy this catalogue? If you admired the amount of time I spent on it, consider leaving a tip for Games4Life to help support future content.

Leave a Reply